WWII Britain strives to be fair.

SEPTEMBER 2, 1939; 11:15 AM LONDON TIME. Prime Minister Chamberlain spoke to the British nation. One line from his speech impacted the lives of everyone listening: “This country is at war with Germany.”

When the prime minister finished speaking, Clara clutched her son’s hand. “We are both here on German passports.” Her voice was edged with fear. “What will happen to us now?“—From my novel Ashes and Ruins, Love, War, and the Homefront

Only weeks before, Clara (my grandmother and the inspiration for my novel) fled from Germany to join her daughter and son in England. She remembered well how German nationals living in Britain had been interned for the duration of WWI. Luckily, as another war began between Britain and her homeland, her daughter, Edith, was safely married to a British citizen. However, Clara and her son, Herman, were suddenly not only refugees but also enemy aliens in a foreign land.

Historically, the internment of civilian nationals of enemy countries was standard practice in most countries. England had universally interned German and Italian nationals during the First World War. As WWII began, the UK Home Office was aware of past failures. They were determined to avoid their previous mistakes.

In 1939, at the outbreak of the war, there were 80,000 enemy aliens in Britain, mostly Germans. The government felt that citizens of Germany and other Axis countries could endanger the nation’s security. Widespread fear of German spies was spread by newspaper articles. Many also feared that refugees would help the military of their native country in the event of an invasion of England.

The British Home Office, which was responsible for national security, civil registration, passports, and immigration, immediately set up a system to determine who threatened security and who did not. Within days after the declaration of war, they announced that all Germans and Austrians between the ages of 16 and 70 would be called before special tribunals. Administered locally, these panels were intended to base their judgments on a fair analysis of the individual’s degree of risk to the British nation. Soon there were 120 tribunal locations set up across the UK, with close to half of them in greater London.

The tribunals did not consist of a panel but were “chaired” by a single individual from the legal profession—a judge, barrister, solicitor, or a lay magistrate from the community. There is no record of any tribunal being chaired by a woman. Tribunal chairs were paid 2 ½ guineas (£2.63), plus travel expenses, for each half-day session, a stipend with the approximate spending value of $300 today. The chair had full authority to judge the refugees and immigrants that came before him. His task was to place enemy aliens in one of three categories:

Category A – A danger to national security and immediately interned

Category B – Those who would not be interned but whose activities would be restricted

Category C – Those who posed no danger and would remain at liberty

In an attempt to avoid unfairness and inconsistencies from one tribunal chairman to another, the Home Office issued detailed guidelines.

The directives noted that refugees who had been “subject to oppression by the Nazi regime on racial, religious, or political grounds” should generally be placed in Category C, unless they were of bad character or had criminal records. Those who had lived in Britain for many years could also be given C status if they showed evidence of good character and loyal intent.

Germans or Austrians who might be reasonably expected to aid their countryman in the event of an invasion must be rated Category A and interned. Tribunals were warned to be especially strict with men of military age or those who had knowledge of mechanics, engineering, or other skills potentially useful to invading forces.

Category B was a kind of compromise designation that allowed for borderline cases. Certainly, better than internment, refugees thus classified faced a string of restrictions. They could not travel more than five miles, own cars, bicycles, cameras, or large-scale maps. They had to abide by a curfew and check in with the local police on a regular basis. Additionally, to hold a job they must secure a special permit from the Ministry of Labor.

Despite these detailed directives, it is likely that individual judges were influenced by their particular politics, class background, experiences, or even their mood that day. A few London chairpersons invited panels to help them, but this was rare, and most tribunals’ decisions reflected the personal attitudes of the single judge.

To help with organization, the local police supplied a clerk for the tribunal. The clerk kept notes and sent out the letters to the aliens, informing them of the time, rules, and place of their interrogation.

The tribunals met in secret in public buildings such as the town hall. The Chelsea tribunal, where Clara was called to appear, was held in the West London County Court in nearby West Kensington. Her letter of summons, like everyone’s, warned her not to tell anyone other than her one allowed companion about the place or date the case would be heard. She was allowed no legal representation, though she was encouraged to submit letters of good character from welfare organizations or British citizens of good standing. Luckily, Clara and Herman had two relatives who fit that description, Edith’s husband George and Clara’s brother Bruno, who had been a naturalized citizen of the UK for many years. The local police or the Home Office could also submit documents on their own to report any problems with the authorities, such as neglecting to report to the local police, infringement of visa restrictions, or arrest.

The speed and efficiency of the Alien Tribunals was impressive. Starting in October of 1939 through January of 1940, 75,665 individual foreign nationals were processed through the system. Close to 600 individuals deemed to be pro-Nazi supporters were classified A and immediately interned. Approximately 6,700 were designated as “doubtful” and placed in Category B. This included my uncle Herman, probably because he was a young man of military age. Ignoring the fact that he was a Jewish refugee, the tribunal mandated that Herman be put under Category B restrictions and confined to his uncle’s home until his US visa arrived. The largest number of those interviewed, 90%, were declared “refugees from Nazi oppression” and left at liberty, as was Clara. Most of these were Jewish, but a few were political refugees. Some long-term residents originally from Germany were also placed in Category C.

The first internment camps were set up wherever there was space (racetracks, schools, vacant barracks). However, the Isle of Man, an island in the middle of the Irish Sea and previously known as a summer resort, soon became the main center for holding enemy aliens.

In the spring of 1940, the so-called “Phoney War” ended. Norway fell to the Nazis, Germany invaded Belgium, the Netherlands, and Denmark, and the British Expeditionary Forces evacuated from Dunkirk. English citizens again whispered their suspicions of anyone with a German accent. The summer brought aerial battles over the south coast of England as the RAF waged a massive defense against the German Luftwaffe. England was gripped by a flood of invasion fear and panic that led to a rash of new arrests and mass internment. Many German and Austrian nationals originally placed in Category B, including Jewish men and hundreds of women, were rounded up and sent to the Isle of Man. Luckily, by then, my Uncle Herman, having finally received his US visa, was safe in California.

In June of 1940, when Britain declared war against Italy, Italian nationals, many of whom had lived and worked for years in England, suddenly joined the ranks of enemy aliens. Immediately, over 4,000 Italian men were rounded up and sent to internment camps without benefit of the tribunal process.

In 1939, Britain intended to handle the problem of enemy aliens more fairly than they had during WWI. However, fear of immigrants, nurtured by the media, resulted in demands for action, and a few leaders were eager to comply. Especially, in the spring and summer of 1940, with the worsening war news and growing fears of German invasion, the good intentions of the government were overridden by the public’s fear of spies and saboteurs. The result was mass internment of immigrants who had previously been allowed their liberty. Fair and reasonable tribunals were trumped by fear.

Note-1: The United States has its own difficult history of internment. In 1941, soon after our declaration of war against Japan, anti-Japanese fever replaced any sense of fairness. Without any attempt at tribunals or other due process, and much to our shame, Japanese-Americans—women, children, naturalized citizens, and American-born Nisei—were rounded up and interned for no other reason than their heritage and ethnicity. Though German nationals were interned during WWII, it was never on the massive, sweeping scale applied to Japanese Americans. For example, neither my father nor my uncle Herman, both German immigrants living in California in 1941, were questioned or interned. In fact, at the time of Pearl Harbor, Herman, not yet a citizen, had just finished basic training in the U.S. Army.

Note 2: Sophie, Edith’s best friend in the novel, Ashes and Ruins, was arrested and interned during this time of growing fear in the UK. I am currently working on a short story about Sophie and her time as an internee on the Isle of Man. In 2027, this story will be one of the offerings exclusively available to my paid subscribers.

*The Phoney War, Waiting for the Blitzkrieg,


Comments

Leave a Reply